• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • ABOUT
    • MEET JOSH AND TERRY
    • GRATITUDE
    • OUR FAVORITE THINGS
  • CONTACT
  • WRITING
    • BOOKS
    • BLOG
  • PODCAST
  • My Courses
  • Log In
  • Cart
Josh & Terry Summers

Josh & Terry Summers

Creative and functional approach to the spiritual path, weaving insights and practices from Yin Yoga, Traditional Chinese Medicine, and ancient wisdom traditions

  • PRACTICE ONLINE
  • ON-DEMAND EDUCATION
    • Short workshops (2-3hrs)
    • In-depth courses (7-10hrs)
    • Teacher Training Modules (25-50hrs)
    • Summers School of Yin Yoga
  • LIVE/ONLINE EVENTS
  • 1:1

Nirvana: The Metaphysical and The Pragmatic

October 25, 2016

In response to my post, “Consciousness, Being and Bliss” I received some questions that I’d like to tackle here. The essence of these questions, I think, boils down to this: “What is spirituality really about? When we engage in a spiritual practice, where is the compass pointed?”

In many forms of spirituality, the compass tends to point towards some kind of ultimate experience or truth (known as metaphysical truth). This experience/truth lies outside normal, everyday experience; it is transcendent to the normal modes of perception, and it is described with qualifiers as being eternal and timeless, blissful and intrinsically liberated.

In Buddhism, nirvana – a placeholder term for freedom and liberation – takes on this kind of transcendent, blissful characteristic.

And a few of you have wondered whether the Buddhist nirvana isn’t just another way of describing the same kind of liberation described in, say, the Upanisads or the Yoga Sutra?

The Buddha compared nirvana to the experience of a fire that is extinguished, or to a flame gone out. In this metaphor, fire refers to a kind of agitation and entrapment that is undesirable. The unawakened mind is compared to being on fire; on fire with craving, hatred and confusion. And this metaphor has led to various interpretations and questions about what it signifies. With the experience of nirvana, is the flame that is snuffed out released to some other dimension of reality whereby it is freed from the agitation inherent to the experience of burning? Or is the flame-gone-out metaphor simply pointing to a way of being that is momentarily released from the agitation and heat of reactivity?

Often, nirvana is compared to its opposite: samsara. Where nirvana is a liberation of some kind, samsara is seen as a kind of bondage to the wheel of a repetitive existence –– usually, referring to an endless wheel of birth, death, rebirth. Here one is bound to this cycle, ad infinitum, until nirvana is realized and, only then, is one no longer trapped by the endless machinations of samsaric existence.

For this discussion,I think it’s helpful to contrast two potential interpretations of these terms – samsara and nirvana –  and compare a metaphysical view with a pragmatic view of their meaning.

A metaphysical view of the samsara/nirvana dichotomy describes a life process of interminable birth, death and re-birth, whereby one is propelled from life to life, consigned to endless rounds of pain, illness, and death. Of course, there will be high points too: love, connection, poetry, good food, happiness, etc. It’s not all suffering, as it is sometimes portrayed. Rather, life is an nonstop oscillation between pleasure and pain. And in this metaphysical model, nirvana is viewed as a literal ‘stepping off’ of this oscillating wheel. The proverbial attainment of nirvana, ie. Enlightenment, is a liberation from life, itself. You’re off the wheel, once and for all.

And certainly, in the Buddha’s words, there are passages suggestive of such a reading. Here the ‘unborn’ is a synonym for nirvana.

“There is, monks, an unborn[1] — unbecome — unmade — unfabricated. If there were not that unborn — unbecome — unmade — unfabricated, there would not be the case that escape from the born — become — made — fabricated would be discerned. But precisely because there is an unborn — unbecome — unmade — unfabricated, escape from the born — become — made — fabricated is discerned.” (Udana, 8.3, Thanissaro Bhikkhu translator)

In other words, nirvana is an escape from the world.

A pragmatic view (and this interpretation is heavily influenced by Stephen Batchelor’s work) by contrast, sees the samsara/nirvana relationship more in terms of this world dynamics. Here samsara is a word that refers to a repetitive way of living that is conditioned by reactivity (greed, hatred and delusion). A popular definition of neurosis might similarly describe a samsaric mode of living: doing the same things again and again, expecting different results, and feeling dismayed by the inevitable frustration that ensues. When, through the development of wisdom and understanding, the flames of greed, hatred and delusion ‘go out,’ (if only temporarily) the experience of nirvana is a freedom of life. The life experience is freed from reactivity, creating the potential for new and creative modes of engagement. And there are interpretations of early Buddhist teachings that do seem to support this view:

Bhikkhu Bodhi, a well-respected American scholar/monk, describes nibbana (Pali for nirvana) as: “[nirvana] itself, the goal of the teaching, is defined quite clearly as freedom from greed, hatred and delusion.” (Purification of Mind)

Another Buddhist scholar, David Kalupahana puts it like this: “What is achieved with the attainment of freedom (nirvana) is the ‘appeasement of dispositions’.” Or another way of saying this is that the experience of nirvana is the “quelling of reactivity.”

So within this distinction between the metaphysical and the pragmatic, we might work hard to transcend the samsaric condition or we might apply ourselves to understand the samsaric condition in order to free ourselves from reactive conditioning.

My intention in presenting these views is not to convince you of the truth of one over the other. Rather, I’m presenting them as a way of encouraging you to examine how they might operate in your practice. Over the years, I have become increasingly sympathetic to the pragmatic perspective. But, ultimately, my hope is that you will come to know for yourself what things lead to the peace of ease, contentment and non-agitation.

Originally published on October 25, 2016

Practice Opportunities: 

  • Weekly Classes with Josh and Terry (Yin Yoga, Yin Meditation, Yin Qi Gong, Yang Qi Gong)

Primary Sidebar

  • Yin Yoga Essentials
  • Qi Harmonization and Yin Yoga
  • Traditional Chinese Medicine
  • Yin Meditation
  • Qi Gong
  • Dharma

Recommended Posts

How Yin Yoga Harmonizes Qi: A Holistic Model – Part 1

The Way of Yin – Receptivity and Creativity on the Path

The Biochemistry of Qi

The Four Principles of Yin Yoga

Footer

Find us around the web

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Instagram

Loading...

Join us!

Walk the path with us and receive our regular updates and reflections, along with a free copy of Josh’s ebook, “The What, Why and How of Yin Yoga” and a FREE 2-week trial to our online Sangha.

Copyright © 2023 · Josh & Terry Summers. Design by Great Oak Circle. Privacy Policy

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings.

Josh & Terry Summers
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.